Getting English Language Students to Speak

I’ve been following an interesting discussion on LinkedIn’s English Language Services Professionals group (you may need to request to join the group before you can access the discussion, not sure).  It is focused on a very common problem, the reluctance of learners to practice speaking in the classroom even when they have good skills. Nicholas Rowe, editor for the Writtenword.edu editing service, has been also been serving as volunteer teacher for a conversational language group in Lapland and is getting very frustrated.

 
“The students all test at B1 or above in the European Language Framework,” Nicholas reports. “They can ‘walk the walk; but are reluctant to ‘talk the talk.’ We have tried 1:1, pairs, reading, conversation on prepared subjects, formal/informal, IT-based/paper-based, games, the news, comic strips—the lot and I am tearing my hair out.”
 
The many responses appear to focus on three different strategies that can be used alone or combined to ease this problem:
  •  Easing the fear of making mistakes
  • Distractions from this fear
  •  Putting students in situations where they are gently “forced” to speak regardless of their fear
A few creative classroom ideas:
  • Sean Daley of the EF Language Foundation in Boston hands out index cards with different, easy-to-discuss topics (“family,” “police” “a good birthday gift”, etc.) to small groups of students. They flip the cards to see the topics, and then have one minute to discuss before switching cards and starting a new topic. The unsupervised, quick discussions “give students a chance to speak freely without error correction” while focusing on topic content.

    The fact that several students will be talking at once also provides a screen of general hubbub so that students have less fear about others listening to their mistakes. (Sean sometimes also plays background music during the activity with the same goal.)
     
  •  Helena Saskoova, an English-Czech translator in the United Kingdom, suggests that when students are split in pairs, those pairs be arranged “according to their willingness to speak—with silent students working together, at least one of them will have to start talking.” She also suggests activities that concentrate on speaking to complete a task together, for instance one drawing a picture and then describing it to their partner with the goal of having them draw their own picture that will be similar but not the same. 
  • Rosemary Nordström, also now a translator in the U.K., reports that when she was a teacher, she found it very effective “to make my opening speech to the class in my then less-than-perfect Swedish and tell them that I had now taken the risk of embarrassing myself and hoped they would do the same. I also related self-depreciating stories of errors I had made in conversation when learning Swedish, the funnier and more self-depreciating the better.”
     
  •  Megan Tootle in Seattle says that “when confronted with similar circumstances, I would take my students on ‘field trips’ to places that required them to speak.” She also would sometimes schedule phone calls for individual students to talk with herself or other native speakers.
A final suggestion that I would make is that adding private practice will allow students to gain both skills and confidence for speaking to “real” classroom audiences. Our ETS English Skills module on pronunciation, which provides positive feedback without without any human (and potentially judgmental audience) is one good tool. Check it out.
What other ideas do you have to help shy students get the most out of conversation classes and build their speaking skills?

—Lia Nigro, TOEIC USA Team

Comments

another idea posted on LinkedIn

and another....

Maria Elizabeth GamaThe fear of making mistakes is one of main causes of silence in foreign language classes. I appreciated the ideas for overcoming this problem. I also suggest the creation of a friendly environment and that the teacher explains his/her sts that making mistakes is part of the language learning process, be it one's native, second or foreign language.

One to One practice by telephone

Not just for business purposes but also to stimulate spontaneous interaction. Most conversation is between two people. So, why speak in front of a classroom? You must feel like they are waiting to interrupt you. A boss making a mistake in front of a secretary. A girl making a mistake getting boys to giggle. Avoid the stress and create as much One to One as possible.

CONVERSATIONS

encouraging ,inciting students to speak or to participate in conversations does not depend only on the students` willingness ,capacities or weaknesses in the foreign language used ,how fluent the person is, sometimes it is more about the student`s personality.In that case, the teacher is not only an instructor but a psychologist who tries to understand how his/her audience`s minds work and how they feel .frankly speaking ,doing this is not easy but it is quite possible and adaptable in one to one class or in ESP CLASSES.

fear can be defeated

The fear from talk is not only a big obstacle before students of English as a second language but is also before those of the first language.
It even prevents one from learning or acquiring many language and life skills. That is why I am calling for creating homogeneous groups inside conversation classrooms where all students feel that they are equal in making mistakes and can start from similar learning lines. Pushing students into real life situations such as presentations before real audience or taking them in a real trip where they find themselves forced to use their learned language would also help us defeat the fear inside students of ESL/EFL. one more point is that students should learn speaking through "the talking circles technique" which organizes students' efforts in this regard and provide all with equal opportunities to speak freely without being afraid of negative feedback.

yet more LinkedIn ideas

It's great how much this post is being discussed on LinkedIn. The four sets of ideas I'm about to post are from the members of the ELT Professionals around the World group, and then there are more to post from at least one other group....

from LinkedIn--Carolyn Campbell

Carolyn CampbellI find that breaking the students into small groups to work together on a project helps them with speaking in the classroom. Then I have then share their results with the class. Since my students speak a variety of native languages, I'm able to pair them with someone who doesn't speak their native tongue, so they have to speak in English. I realize that most classrooms don't have that luxury. In that case, I found that doing an in-class group activity with some guidance from me at first helps, as many times they may not have the vocabulary to join the conversation.

LinkedIn--Donna Reale

Donna RealeGood summary, Carolyn. I agree. Tonight, I will try an ice-breaker with my students using this technique. I will ask them to think of three things for which they are grateful (a Harvard psychologist recommended this as a motivational tool) and discuss them with their partner. I'll also put a model sentence or two on the board to help them answer the question. Then we'll discuss as a whole class.

[Later...] The students really participated; I think they "got it." I thank Harvard psychologist Sean Anchor for his idea (in a video clip) which I accessed through LinkedIn's Adult Literacy Network.

LinkedIn: Christine O'Neill

Christine O'NeillI've found that students love talking about food! But any topic based on their personal experience works, but even more than that, based on their needs. If they have a need to communicate a message then they will focus on the message, rather than their errors. So all the usual kind of information gap activities we use in Communicative Language Teaching will work.


The other secret is breaking down any activity into its tiniest steps, and giving them lots of time to practice in order to build up confidence, including old-fashioned drilling for pronunciation. I use a lot of dialogue building, in which I elicit directly from the students to the white-board a complete dialogue, based on some practical, real-life situations. After they've been drilled in the pronunciation of the conversation, chorally and individually, they are able to practice in closed pairs, then open pairs, and then with their own variations. After such controlled speaking activities they develop confidence quickly and enjoy the occasions in which you set them loose to speak freely about their own personal experiences. It works for me anyway!

LinkedIn: Jo Gakonga

Jo GakongaThere are some really great ideas here - if you want a couple of other ideas, there's a webinar on this at:
http://my.brainshark.com/Encouraging-your-learners-to-speak-in-class-438702954

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <iframe><embed><div><span><p style><br><br/><a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl><dt><dd><h1><h2><h3><p><table><tr><td><tbody><img><b><i><strike><div class="rteindent1"><div class="rteindent2"><div class="rteindent3"><div class="rteindent4"><p class="rteindent1"><p class="rteindent2"><p class="rteindent3"><p class="rteindent4"><h1 class="rteindent1"><h1 class="rteindent2"><h1 class="rteindent3"><h1 class="rteindent4"><h2 class="rteindent1"><h2 class="rteindent2"><h2 class="rteindent3"><h2 class="rteindent4"><h3 class="rteindent1"><h3 class="rteindent2"><h3 class="rteindent3"><h3 class="rteindent4"><h4><h5><sup>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.